Gender-Motivated Violence Act

Understanding the NYC GMVA

The New York City Victims of Gender-Motivated Violence Act (GMVA), sometimes referred to as the Victims of Gender-Motivated Violence Protection Law (GMVPL) allows survivors to seek damages from their abusers and responsible entities.

The Gender-Motivated Violence Act provides a powerful legal framework for addressing sexual abuse personal injury cases. By recognizing gender-based violence as a civil rights violation, the GMVA offers victims a critical pathway to justice, empowering them to hold their abusers accountable and seek the compensation they deserve. For victims and their advocates, understanding and utilizing the provisions of the GMVA is a crucial step in the fight against sexual abuse and gender-motivated violence.

What is the Gender-Motivated Violence Protection Law?

The Gender-Motivated Violence Protection Law (GMVPL), part of the New York City Administrative Code, was established to offer protection to both men and women against gender-based violence, which includes sexual assaults. This law provides survivors the right to pursue legal action for physical, emotional, and financial injuries stemming from the assaults.

Courts in New York have acknowledged that acts of sexual assault and abuse can qualify as gender-motivated violence. As a result, survivors of such abuse, regardless of gender, can potentially seek financial compensation through this law—whether the abuser is male or female.

Key points of the law include the following:

Civil Remedy: The GMVPL establishes a civil cause of action, enabling survivors of gender-motivated violence to file civil lawsuits against their abusers and responsible parties or institutions, allowing them to seek financial compensation for their damages.
Gender-Motivated Violence: The law covers violence driven by gender bias, which includes any violent act committed due to a person’s gender. Sexual assaults and other sex crimes classified as misdemeanors or felonies under state or federal law are considered under this definition.
Applicable Only in NYC: Since this law is part of the New York City code, it is limited to incidents within the five boroughs. For victims to have a valid legal claim under this statute, the violent act must have taken place within the city.

This pioneering law provides a significant legal avenue for survivors to obtain justice and recover damages, even for cases of sexual abuse that occurred many years ago.

Lawsuits filed under the GMVPL can target not only the perpetrators but also entities or organizations that contributed to, enabled, or were complicit in the gender-motivated act of violence. This can include:

Institutions- medical facilities, correctional facilities, schools, rehab facilities etc.
Other parties are legally accountable for the actions of their staff, volunteers, or contractors.
Or possibly an employer.

What Does “Gender Motivated Violence” Mean?

Gender-motivated violence refers to acts of violence committed against an individual, at least in part, because of their gender. This can include acts of physical or sexual violence that are motivated by bias, hostility, or discrimination toward the victim's gender identity. The courts look at whether the perpetrator’s actions were rooted in prejudice or animus related to the victim’s gender, and proving this requires a deliberate and targeted approach.

The phrase "gender-based animus" refers to hostility, ill will, or prejudice against someone based on their gender. This can manifest in various forms, including discrimination, violence, or derogatory statements, and can be directed towards individuals because of their actual or perceived gender identity or expression. Essentially, it's a form of gender bias that negatively impacts individuals and society.

Amendment Details: 2022 Changes to the Gender-Motivated Violence Act

In January 2022, the New York City Council passed significant amendments to the Gender-Motivated Violence Act (GMVA) that expanded legal opportunities for survivors of gender-based violence. These amendments introduced two critical provisions aimed at increasing access to justice for victims:

2-Year Lookback Window: One of the most impactful changes is establishing a temporary 2-year lookback window for survivors to file civil lawsuits, regardless of when the violence occurred. This window, which began on March 1, 2023, and extends until March 1, 2025, gives victims of past gender-motivated violence a chance to seek justice even if the incident took place years or decades ago.
Extended Statute of Limitations: The amendment also extends the statute of limitations, giving survivors more time to bring their claims forward. Previously, victims had a limited timeframe to file a lawsuit, but under the new law, survivors can file claims within 7 to 9 years from the date of the incident. This extension allows survivors who may have needed more time to process their trauma the opportunity to still seek legal recourse.

Legal Criteria for Proving Gender Motivation

Proving gender motivation under the Gender-Motivated Violence Act (GMVA) is one of the most critical aspects of a claim. Unlike typical personal injury cases, where the focus is on the act of violence itself, claims under the GMVA require the plaintiff to establish that the violence was motivated by the victim's gender. This additional layer of complexity often calls for careful legal strategy and the presentation of specific types of evidence to meet the legal standard of proving “gender motivation.”

Let’s look at the key elements in proving gender motivation:

Hostile Statements or Conduct: In a claim of gender-motivated violence, one of the strongest pieces of evidence is showing that the perpetrator expressed hostility based on gender before, during, or after the violent act. This could include making derogatory comments, using offensive language, or making threats that specifically target the victim's gender. Courts will consider whether the perpetrator used language or behavior that shows prejudice against the victim's gender.
Pattern of Behavior: If the person who harmed you has a history of mistreating people of the same gender as you, it can show that they are targeting you because of your gender. Past experiences of violence, harassment, or threatening behavior can also help prove that the harm you experienced was because of gender-based prejudice.
Disparity in Treatment: One way to demonstrate gender motivation is by comparing how the perpetrator treats people of different genders. If the attacker consistently mistreats or is violent towards people of one gender while treating others differently, this may be seen as evidence of gender-based animosity.
Perpetrator’s History and Attitudes: Evidence from the perpetrator’s past, such as previous convictions for gender-based violence or documented incidents of expressing gender animus, can be used to support the claim that the violence was motivated by gender. Additionally, testimony from people who can speak to the perpetrator's history of sexist attitudes or discriminatory behavior may also be relevant.

How Do I Prove My Claim?

To successfully prove a claim under the GMVPL, you need to establish the following key elements:

Location: The assault must have taken place in one of the five boroughs.
Act of Violence: Demonstrate that an act of violence occurred. This includes physical assault, sexual abuse, or any other form of violence that results in harm.
Gender Motivation: Show that the act of violence was motivated, at least in part, by the victim's gender. This can include evidence that the perpetrator expressed gender-based animus.

Types of Supporting Evidence

Medical Records

Medical records provide not only proof of the violence and its consequences but also may include statements the victim made to medical personnel about the incident. If the perpetrator’s attack involved references to the victim’s gender or there were specific gender-based injuries (e.g., sexual assault), these details will be critical in supporting a gender-motivation claim.

Witness Testimonies

Witnesses who overheard gender-based comments or saw discriminatory behavior leading up to or during the act of violence are crucial. Testimonies from friends, neighbors, coworkers, or even bystanders can corroborate the victim’s account of the violence and its motivation. Their statements may reinforce claims that the perpetrator’s actions were directly related to gender bias.

Communications

Emails, text messages, social media posts, or any other forms of communication that contain gender-based threats, slurs, or evidence of hostility toward the victim’s gender can play a vital role in proving gender motivation. These records provide concrete, tangible proof that the perpetrator’s violence was linked to gender-based animus.

Police Reports

Law enforcement records documenting the perpetrator’s gender-based statements during the investigation or arrest can serve as crucial evidence. If officers note that the perpetrator expressed gender-based bias at the time of the incident or if the victim shared concerns about such bias, this information will be critical.

Photographic Evidence

If the violence resulted in physical injuries that are often gender-targeted (e.g., sexual violence), photographic evidence can help illustrate the nature of the assault and support claims of gender-based motivation.

Social Media Activity

Sometimes, a perpetrator’s social media history can provide insight into their mindset and biases. Posts or comments that show a history of gender-based animus, derogatory remarks about a specific gender, or violent ideologies can be used to demonstrate that the violence was rooted in gender bias.

Psychological Impact Evidence

In addition to physical injuries, victims may also experience long-term emotional and psychological harm due to gender-based violence. Records from therapists or mental health professionals documenting emotional trauma, PTSD, or anxiety stemming from the gender-targeted nature of the violence can strengthen the case for compensatory damages.

Personal Testimony

The victim’s own detailed account of the assault, emphasizing any instances where the perpetrator’s actions or words indicated gender-based hostility, is essential in painting a clear picture for the court. Victims pursuing a claim under the GMVA need to be as detailed and thorough as possible when presenting these types of evidence. A strong case links the violence directly to gender bias, demonstrating that the attack was not just random but rooted in discriminatory motives.

Challenges in Proving Gender Motivation

While the evidence mentioned above can provide a strong foundation for a gender-motivated violence claim, proving gender motivation may present challenges. The defense may argue that the violence was not related to gender but was instead a result of other factors, such as personal disputes or random acts of violence. For this reason, the plaintiff’s attorney must present a clear and well-documented argument that links the violence to gender bias, using as much corroborating evidence as possible to meet the burden of proof.

Steps to Take After Gender-Motivated Violence

For survivors of gender-motivated violence, navigating the legal process can be overwhelming. Below is a comprehensive guide outlining the essential steps victims should take to protect their rights and build a strong legal case under the GMVA:

Seek Immediate Medical Attention: After an act of violence, your health and safety should be the top priority. Seek immediate medical treatment for any injuries, and be sure to document all treatments received. Request copies of your medical records, which will serve as crucial evidence if you decide to pursue a claim.
Report the Incident to Authorities: Filing a police report is critical, even if the incident occurred long ago. The police report will serve as an official record of the violence, and law enforcement may conduct an investigation that uncovers further evidence of gender-based animus.
Preserve Evidence: In addition to medical records and police reports, gather and preserve any other forms of evidence that may support your case. This includes communication records, photographs of injuries, and any other documentation that points to gender-based violence.
Collect Witness Information: If there were witnesses to the violence or to its immediate aftermath, gather their contact information. To reiterate, witness statements can corroborate your account and help strengthen your case.
Contact a Gender-Motivated Violence Act Attorney: It is critical to seek legal counsel as soon as possible. An experienced attorney can help guide you through the legal process, evaluate your case, and ensure that your rights are protected. Your attorney will help you gather additional evidence, file necessary paperwork, and represent you in court if needed.
Document Your Experience: Write down your own account of the incident as soon as possible. The details are crucial in helping your attorney build a case. Include any interactions or statements made by the perpetrator that suggest gender bias or hostility.

Pursue Counseling and Emotional Support: The emotional toll of gender-motivated violence can be significant. Seek counseling or therapy to address the psychological impact of the violence. Not only will this support your healing, but it may also serve as evidence of emotional distress in your claim for damages.

Do I Have a Case?

You may be eligible to file a civil lawsuit under the Gender-Motivated Violence Act if:

You experienced harm and suffered losses as a result of a sexual assault or violent crime motivated, at least in part, by your gender and
The gender-motivated assault took place in one of the five boroughs of New York City

It's important to understand that while these abusive acts are criminal offenses, claims filed under the Gender-Motivated Violence Act are civil cases, entirely separate from any criminal proceedings. This means you can still pursue a claim even if your abuser was never charged with a crime or if they were charged but not convicted.

Our experienced team is here to discuss your case and help determine whether you are eligible to file a lawsuit under the NYC GMVA.

Schedule A Consultation

What Damages Can I Recover Under New York's Gender-Motivated Violence Act?

Compensatory Damages

Compensatory damages are intended to cover the actual losses and expenses you have incurred as a result of the gender-motivated violence. These damages can include:

Medical Expenses: You can recover costs related to medical treatment, including emergency room visits, hospital stays, surgeries, medications, and ongoing therapy. This also covers future medical expenses anticipated due to the lasting impact of the abuse.
Loss of Enjoyment of Life: If the abuse has diminished your ability to enjoy life and engage in activities you once found pleasurable, you can seek damages for this loss. This encompasses the impact on your overall quality of life.

Lost Wages: If the violence has caused you to miss work or affected your ability to earn income, you can seek compensation for lost wages. This also extends to future loss of earning capacity if the trauma impacts your long-term employment prospects.
Pain and Suffering: Victims can be compensated for the physical pain and emotional suffering endured due to the violence. This non-economic damage takes into account the severity and duration of your suffering.

Property Damage: If the violence caused damage to your property, you could recover the cost of repairing or replacing the damaged items.
Psychological Counseling: The law recognizes the profound emotional and psychological trauma that can be caused by gender-motivated violence. Compensation for therapy, counseling, and psychiatric care aimed at helping you recover from mental anguish and emotional distress is included.

Michael S. Lamonsoff, gender motivated violence act lawyer in NYC

Why Choose the Law Offices of Michael S. Lamonsoff for Your Gender-Motivated Violence Act Claim?

Filing a claim under New York's Gender-Motivated Violence Act (GMVA) is a critical step toward achieving justice and securing compensation for the harm you have endured. Working with the right personal injury attorney in New York City can make all the difference in your case.

Our firm, led by Michael S. Lamonsoff, has a proven track record of successfully advocating for our clients. We take the time to listen to your experiences, understand your needs, and tailor our approach to fit your specific circumstances. Our compassionate team is dedicated to providing personalized legal support, ensuring you feel heard, valued, and supported throughout the legal process.

Even better, we’re known for our aggressive and tenacious client advocacy. Michael S. Lamonsoff, often called "The Bull," is relentless in his pursuit of justice. Our firm is committed to holding perpetrators accountable and securing the maximum compensation for our clients. From the moment you contact our firm, we provide comprehensive legal support every step of the way. We handle all aspects of your case, allowing you to focus on your healing and recovery while we fight for your rights.

If you or a loved one has been a victim of gender-motivated violence, don’t wait to seek the justice and compensation you deserve. The Law Offices of Michael S. Lamonsoff are here to provide the expert legal support and aggressive advocacy you need. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward reclaiming your life. Let us fight for you.

Member of:

Board of Directors of NY State Trial Lawyers Association
American Association for Justice
NY County Lawyers Association

Educated at:

University of Arizona
Benjamin N. Cordozo School of Law
Double post-masters degrees in psychology at Columbia University

Awards:

6X Super Lawyers Panel
Million Dollar and Multi Million Dollar Advocates Forum